On Monday, March 7, 2022, Andrea paz <gamberucci.andrea@gmail.com> wrote:
>( Phyllis):
> When I used the ffmpeg/tiff render format, it created the toc file but it was empty even then.
> Also ran the CinGG version of 11/2016 and 2/2018; in both cases the toc file was either empty (the earlier ones) or just the first 4 lines.
> So I think it never worked right and the workaround as Andrea tested it to create the toc file manually.

Sorry to insist, but I think DPX support is very important.

It would take more testing by other users. As I wrote in a previous
message, some versions work for me, and even in Arch, DPX and PNG used
to work for me (not anymore, now).

@IgorBeg
Please, can you test the rendering of a sequence of images (it only
takes a few seconds), since you normally use Ubuntu 16?

> I assume the ffmpeg command line creates it?  I have not had the chance to try that yet.  Does it?

FFmpeg creates the images with a command (muxer) that implies %05d in
the name and then, thanks to the image2 command (demuxer), it reads
them (without the need to create a TOC file) and creates the video. It
occurs to me that CinGG presets create the images via %05d and then,
instead of being read by image2, the TOC file (not the video file!) is
created and can be imported into CinGG (or other program). Perhaps a
version of "imagelist.sh" is implemented? In short, the difference
between ffmpeg and CinGG is the creation of the TOC file.

I remember that my hypothesis about the problem is the management of
absolute/relative paths, since the TOC is created and works: only the
links are missing. 


I am not sure it was designed as cross-application support? I mean, cingg can  load both TOC types, so it works... 

Are you concerned about more self-contained toc file for inter-application operability  or self-documentability reasons? 

How other apps (like Natron?) handle this? 



Is it possible to trace a patch that has touched
the paths? If not, I'll say again that it's better to delete these
presets and the related entries in the manual altogether.

[ffmpeg reference:
https://www.ffmpeg.org/faq.html#How-do-I-encode-single-pictures-into-movies_003f
https://www.ffmpeg.org/ffmpeg-formats.html#image2-2
https://www.ffmpeg.org/ffmpeg-formats.html#image2-1]