Keyframe Adjustments Not Seen in Render
I've added a couple keyframes to adjust the curves in Histogram Bezier at the end of a clip. When I play in the compositor I see the change (lower highlights as I pan into a scene lit by the sun) as expected. When I render, either background rendering or a full render for output, it seems the changes are ignored and the curves don't change with time. Am I missing something? Regards, Mark
Hi Mark, could you show a screenshot, please? IgorBeg Mark Goldberg via Cin wrote:
I've added a couple keyframes to adjust the curves in Histogram Bezier at the end of a clip. When I play in the compositor I see the change (lower highlights as I pan into a scene lit by the sun) as expected. When I render, either background rendering or a full render for output, it seems the changes are ignored and the curves don't change with time.
Am I missing something?
On Mon, Jan 24, 2022 at 2:30 AM Igor BEGHETTO via Cin < [email protected]> wrote:
Hi Mark, could you show a screenshot, please?
IgorBeg
You can see the changes to the curves in the three screenshots at different points on the timeline. It is reflected in the compositor, but not in the rendered output. Regards, Mark
Mark Goldberg via Cin wrote:
I've added a couple keyframes to adjust the curves in Histogram Bezier at the end of a clip. When I play in the compositor I see the change (lower highlights as I pan into a scene lit by the sun) as expected. When I render, either background rendering or a full render for output, it seems the changes are ignored and the curves don't change with time.
Am I missing something? -- Cin mailing list [email protected] https://lists.cinelerra-gg.org/mailman/listinfo/cin
Thank you for the screenshots Mark. It is really strange. What are your settings for Preferences, Format, Render? I don't know the data (codec, pixel format, ...) about your footage but, if you want to do a test, make a copy of your project using "Save as..." and in that "clone" try to change the parameters as below: - Preferences...-> Apperance-> Color section YUV color space: BT709 YUV color range: MPEG - Format...-> Video section Color model: RGBA-8bit - Render: File Format: FFMPEG | mp4 Video Preset--> Compression: h264.mp4 Bitrate: 0 Quality: -1 Pixels: yuv420p Il 24/01/2022 12:02, Mark Goldberg via Cin ha scritto:
You can see the changes to the curves in the three screenshots at different points on the timeline. It is reflected in the compositor, but not in the rendered output.
The footage is 10 bit F-log 4k60 H.265. Color model is RGBA-Float. I'm rendering to H.265 yuv420p h265_nvenc.mp4 to play on non HDR systems. Card is Nvidia GTX1050. I can try different render formats. Regards, Mark On Wed, Jan 26, 2022 at 2:13 AM Igor BEGHETTO via Cin < [email protected]> wrote:
Thank you for the screenshots Mark. It is really strange. What are your settings for Preferences, Format, Render?
I don't know the data (codec, pixel format, ...) about your footage but, if you want to do a test, make a copy of your project using "Save as..." and in that "clone" try to change the parameters as below: - Preferences...-> Apperance-> Color section YUV color space: BT709 YUV color range: MPEG - Format...-> Video section Color model: RGBA-8bit - Render: File Format: FFMPEG | mp4 Video Preset--> Compression: h264.mp4 Bitrate: 0 Quality: -1 Pixels: yuv420p
Il 24/01/2022 12:02, Mark Goldberg via Cin ha scritto:
You can see the changes to the curves in the three screenshots at different points on the timeline. It is reflected in the compositor, but not in the rendered output. -- Cin mailing list [email protected] https://lists.cinelerra-gg.org/mailman/listinfo/cin
I have done a test here using a video from https://www.eoshd.com/news/download-my-4k-hdr-10bit-h-265-videos-shot-with-t... (direct link to https://drive.google.com/open?id=1jcSp9JZR8eFKq9jTXNLbG5nFIjWhD8YJ ). It is a 4k video H.265-10bit@25fps. I used F_log3d and Histogram Bezier plugins (four points in Polynominal mode on two keyframes) for the clips. Because my Notebook is very old I must use Proxy. Rendering to H.264 and H.265 but NEVER _nvenc (I can not) with Proxy enabled, to save time and to see the output, and then the Final Render. Here it seems all good. I think that the problem might be _nvenc. All (almost) my Settings for that below (I don't know if it can help): ===================================== - File Source: P1000111.MP4 hevc (H265) 3840x2160 @25.00 yuv420p10le - Preferences: - Playback A TAB - Video Out section Play everyframe = unchecked Video Driver: X11 Use direct x11 render if possible = checked - Appearance TAB - Color section YUV color space: BT709 YUV color range: MPEG - Format: - Video section Frame rate: 25.00 Width: 3840 Height: 2160 Color model: RGBA-8bit (also RGBA-FLOAT) - Proxy: Scale factor: 1/8 Rescaled to project size (FFMEG only) = unchecked File Format: FFMPEG | pro Video Preset Compression: prores_ks.pro Bitrate: 0 Quality: -1 Pixels: yuva444p10le - Render #1: File Format: FFMPEG | mp4 Video Preset Compression: h265.mp4 Bitrate: 0 Quality: -1 Pixels: yuv420p - Render #2: File Format: FFMPEG | mp4 Video Preset Compression: h264.mp4 Bitrate: 0 Quality: -1 Pixels: yuv420p ===================================== Il 26/01/2022 10:31, Mark Goldberg ha scritto:
The footage is 10 bit F-log 4k60 H.265. Color model is RGBA-Float. I'm rendering to H.265 yuv420p h265_nvenc.mp4 to play on non HDR systems. Card is Nvidia GTX1050.
I can try different render formats.
Thanks. I tried again, starting with the same settings and it worked correctly this time. I have no idea what was wrong or what might have been different. This video format (from a Fuji X-T4) is very challenging to work with. Regards, Mark On Thu, Jan 27, 2022 at 1:46 AM Igor BEGHETTO <[email protected]> wrote:
I have done a test here using a video from
https://www.eoshd.com/news/download-my-4k-hdr-10bit-h-265-videos-shot-with-t... (direct link to https://drive.google.com/open?id=1jcSp9JZR8eFKq9jTXNLbG5nFIjWhD8YJ ). It is a 4k video H.265-10bit@25fps. I used F_log3d and Histogram Bezier plugins (four points in Polynominal mode on two keyframes) for the clips. Because my Notebook is very old I must use Proxy. Rendering to H.264 and H.265 but NEVER _nvenc (I can not) with Proxy enabled, to save time and to see the output, and then the Final Render. Here it seems all good. I think that the problem might be _nvenc. All (almost) my Settings for that below (I don't know if it can help): ===================================== - File Source: P1000111.MP4 hevc (H265) 3840x2160 @25.00 yuv420p10le
- Preferences: - Playback A TAB - Video Out section Play everyframe = unchecked Video Driver: X11 Use direct x11 render if possible = checked - Appearance TAB - Color section YUV color space: BT709 YUV color range: MPEG
- Format: - Video section Frame rate: 25.00 Width: 3840 Height: 2160 Color model: RGBA-8bit (also RGBA-FLOAT)
- Proxy: Scale factor: 1/8 Rescaled to project size (FFMEG only) = unchecked File Format: FFMPEG | pro Video Preset Compression: prores_ks.pro Bitrate: 0 Quality: -1 Pixels: yuva444p10le
- Render #1: File Format: FFMPEG | mp4 Video Preset Compression: h265.mp4 Bitrate: 0 Quality: -1 Pixels: yuv420p
- Render #2: File Format: FFMPEG | mp4 Video Preset Compression: h264.mp4 Bitrate: 0 Quality: -1 Pixels: yuv420p =====================================
Il 26/01/2022 10:31, Mark Goldberg ha scritto:
The footage is 10 bit F-log 4k60 H.265. Color model is RGBA-Float. I'm rendering to H.265 yuv420p h265_nvenc.mp4 to play on non HDR systems. Card is Nvidia GTX1050.
I can try different render formats.
Are you saying it worked with your settings or mine? If your, could you tell us which they are? Thanks. IgorBeg Il 27/01/2022 15:35, Mark Goldberg ha scritto:
Thanks. I tried again, starting with the same settings and it worked correctly this time. I have no idea what was wrong or what might have been different. This video format (from a Fuji X-T4) is very challenging to work with.
I'm saying I can't reproduce the problem. I loaded the same project and it worked without changes. I will do some more testing. Regards, Mark On Sat, Jan 29, 2022 at 1:32 AM Igor BEGHETTO <[email protected]> wrote:
Are you saying it worked with your settings or mine? If your, could you tell us which they are? Thanks.
IgorBeg
Il 27/01/2022 15:35, Mark Goldberg ha scritto:
Thanks. I tried again, starting with the same settings and it worked correctly this time. I have no idea what was wrong or what might have been different. This video format (from a Fuji X-T4) is very challenging to work with.
participants (2)
-
Igor BEGHETTO -
Mark Goldberg