[Cin] flac 1.4.0

[Phyllis Smith]

Andrea, thanks for excellent and thorough tests.  I just do not understand
why I get different results.  I repeated my small tests again -- the
previous last test was a very big one with 671,435 frames and not a normal
case because it was a recording of a TV program with 11 audio channels.
But this small one has only 2 audio channels.  Maybe the difference is
because they are video as well as audio (which does not make any sense)?

** rendered 2712 frames in* 0.189 secs, 14349.206 fps / Size=11474491* /
1.3.2 FLAC library

** rendered 2712 frames in *0.185 secs, 14659.459 fps / Size=11448186* /
Compression-level=0
** rendered 2712 frames in 0.319 secs, 8501.567 fps   / Size= 9448273 /
Compression-level=5
** rendered 2712 frames in 0.656 secs, 4134.146 fps   / Size= 8948373 /
Compression-level=8

As you can see from above, compression-level of 0 most closely matches in
time and size of the original output from 1.3.2 versus 1.4.0.  I am going
to do more tests and try on Ubuntu 16 and Debian 32-bit 11.

Any thoughts??


On Sun, Sep 18, 2022 at 1:50 AM Andrea paz <gamberucci.andrea at gmail.com>
wrote:

> I added wav-type sources on top of the previous mp3-type sources to
> make the project a little bigger.
> Tests confirm that 'compression 5' is more efficient than 'compression
> 0'. I do not understand why. Phyllis' results seem more logical to me.
>
> I also add the results obtained using the flac preset of ffmpeg always
> at compression 0; 5 and 8. The fps are comparable but not the size
> (due to optimization patches?).
>
> Flac:
> ** rendered 26152 frames in 2.886 secs, 9061.677 fps, size 63.2 MiB
>
> ** rendered 26152 frames in 1.637 secs, 15975.565 fps, size 57.8 MiB
>
> ** rendered 26152 frames in 3.368 secs, 7764.846 fps, size 56.8 MiB
>
>
> ffmpeg flac:
> ** rendered 26152 frames in 3.102 secs, 8430.690 fps, size 138.4 MiB
>
> ** rendered 26152 frames in 1.649 secs, 15859.309 fps, size 127.8 MiB
>
> ** rendered 26152 frames in 2.937 secs, 8904.324 fps, size 126.4 MiB
>
>
> Flac 1.3 (appimage):
> ** rendered 26152 frames in 1.445 secs, 18098.270 fps, 63.4 MiB**
>
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <https://lists.cinelerra-gg.org/pipermail/cin/attachments/20220918/a5347e9a/attachment.htm>